|
Post by Telso on Jan 4, 2019 0:15:53 GMT 10
Since we've now officially reached this decade's last year, I think it's a good occasion for reflecting back on the popular songs that were huge throughout the last 10 years. I will give them some thought, a rating and throw them in an approximate ranking purely based on how I enjoyed them. To make things more interesting a random generator pick the year for me and I pick one of that year's biggest hits at will. This is my main contribution to stir up some maybe needed conversation Hopefully y'all will not be too judgemental of my tastes Ranking:Carly Rae Jepsen - Call Me Maybe (2012): 9/10Drake - Nice for What (2018): 8.5/10The Weeknd - The Hills (2015): 8/10Mike Posner - I Took a Pill in Ibiza (SeeB Remix) (2016): 7.5/10Justin Bieber - What Do You Mean? (2015): 7/10Pharrell Williams - Happy (2014): 6.5/10Drake - God's Plan (2018): 5/10Miley Cyrus - We Can't Stop (2013): 4/10Rihanna feat. Drake - Work (2016): 2/10
SharksFan99 likes this
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 4, 2019 0:30:27 GMT 10
Miley Cyrus - We Can't Stop (2013)
Oh yeah Miley's awkward rebellion phase… Watching images is even worse in hindsight as it all looks phony and pretty forced, especially all those annoying mimics she had. That boyish look also really didn't fit her at all. But I guess she had fun? As far as this song goes it sure stood out at the time due to the novelty of it being an overtly urban-sounding club banger and avoided the heavy, abrasive, hard-hitting synths a lot of Pop songs were using. It's a lot more building, empty spaced and atmospheric, highly reminding me of what came to be popular in the second part of the decade. The tone is sad and quite melancholic throughout (especially thanks to the piano line on the verses and the low-frequency buzzing synth on the choruses make me feel like being in an anxious, desperately silent waiting room), which is quite unique among party songs which I can give praise for. Except I'd have to take immediately that praise back because that same tone is completely incoherent with what the song stands for. It's a song about Miley's independence and how she spends her wilderness of a youth (like "having fun with molly" or "taking the line in the bathroom"), so why being so muted? Shouldn't this instead be as in-your-face of a Pop song as possible? Why do I have this impression of listening to someone mourning the death of a party The only thing I can image is that she vaped too hard and is in a half-conscious state (she's "turned up yeah" after all), but that still doesn't make her bold statement the less understated. Take "Dirrty" by Christina Aguilera for instance. It's a song that goes completely nuts in its overt sexuality, very much self-conscious and takes the time to make a complete spectacle out of it. It has a loud presence, succeeding in making you sure the new Christina is here. That is how a rebellion song should be done, Miley.
Then there's the twerking promotion which was its introduction to a lot of people, despite being a staple of the New Orleans' Bounce scene. It's up to you to decide if it's negative cultural approbation to introduce it to the masses in a situation where she wants to appear "slutty", but I certainly think it only padded her already annoying palette of mimics further more and adds to the incoherency between the image and the sound. Who wants to twerk on something like this?
It's honestly not that bad of a song (the autotuned yeaaaahhs in the bridge being the only musically awful part), it just doesn't work for what it tries to be and falls short because of that. At least it definitely succeeded in making people talk about it. 4/10
SharksFan99 likes this
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
|
0 |
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 4, 2019 6:47:44 GMT 10
I disliked that song too! What do you think of Sia's Cheap Thrills?
Telso likes this
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 4, 2019 7:13:38 GMT 10
What do you think of Sia's Cheap Thrills? You'll see when I come to it But I can already tell it's easily one of the better of its year (which also isn't saying that much).
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 4, 2019 7:33:00 GMT 10
My reviews won't be as passionate as that first one since 10 years worth of hits is a lot to cover!
The Weeknd - The Hills (2015)
The story of a pretty terrible human being keeping it low profile in its quest of adultery and drugs, with the fear of being discovered. Facing the reality that he's not his own self anymore without abusing on the coke. This tale of terrible human facets is transformed into a horror of a dark song, that's the premise of "The Hills". The Weeknd has always been a popular figure of the Alt-R&B scene in the indiesphere since the early-10s, particularly standing for themes of lonely sensuality and hedonistic escapism. And this song follows his line of dark R&B quite to the perfection. I absolutely love the use of the hi-hits borrowed from Trap here (some of the best ever) in how they add to dirty grittiness of the song, as well as the screams leading to the chorus. The ethereal bridge is a nice break from the heaviness. And while "the hills have eyes" is kind of a clever pun relative to the story, but it's still probably a bit too on-the-nose of a reference (especially since it basically the title to this song).
The thing holding me back from giving a higher note to this song is how draining of a journey putting it on every time. 8/10
Mike Posner - I Took a Pill in Ibiza (SeeB Remix) (2016)
The remix is far and wide better than the terribly whiny and preachy Folk Pop original. The themes of self-realisation and coming up with your own failures works better when the EDM highlights the confusion and the depravity, having less of self-importance side and more of an unappealing afterparty regret one. A fairly engaging story told by a former one-hit wonder in how surprising and brutally honest he can be about himself. The production is fairly nice, somehow managing to give Tropical House's typical warmth and poppiness an empty room melancholia feeling. The echoing of the voice is also a great touch, perfectly highlighting the singer's emotional state. All in all a strong song, especially for this worthless of a year. It's still a little too overly pathetic for my tastes. 7.5/10
Carly Rae Jepsen - Call Me Maybe (2012)
This might be the ultimate guilty pleasure song to end all guilty pleasure songs. I probably won't regret saying that overall Carly Rae Jepsen is the best Pop stars of the 2010s. She especially killed it back in 2015 with her "EMO-T-ION"-era. So it's kind of sad to me that for most people she's been only known for being the author of this almost-novelty song. But even then I can't hide that I really like this song. It's a really basic sugary confession, but I think it works incredibly well in its simplicity. A little teenybopper about the themes of infatuation and longing, not sappy nor sneary where a lot of Teen Pop songs tend to fail (sometimes spectacularly). It's actually so simple and not over-the-top with its teenage attitude that it actually gathered a wide appeal among the adult demography (charting even very high on the "Adult Top 10" and "Adult Contemporary" Billboard charts). And that's probably the magic of this song: a innocent well-crafted piece that's just trying to be catchy and sweet, and that's ok! The string arrangements that pop each time and the build-up towards the chorus are incredibly addicting. Even the clip is pretty hilarious. Overall one of the greatest Pop classics of this decade. 9/10
|
|
|
Post by SharksFan99 on Jan 4, 2019 10:49:08 GMT 10
Carly Rae Jepsen - Call Me Maybe (2012)This might be the ultimate guilty pleasure song to end all guilty pleasure songs. I probably won't regret saying that overall Carly Rae Jepsen is the best Pop stars of the 2010s. She especially killed it back in 2015 with her "EMO-T-ION"-era. So it's kind of sad to me that for most people she's been only known for being the author of this almost-novelty song. But even then I can't hide that I really like this song. It's a really basic sugary confession, but I think it works incredibly well in its simplicity. A little teenybopper about the themes of infatuation and longing, not sappy nor sneary where a lot of Teen Pop songs tend to fail (sometimes spectacularly). It's actually so simple and not over-the-top with its teenage attitude that it actually gathered a wide appeal among the adult demography (charting even very high on the "Adult Top 10" and "Adult Contemporary" Billboard charts). And that's probably the magic of this song: a innocent well-crafted piece that's just trying to be catchy and sweet, and that's ok! The string arrangements that pop each time and the build-up towards the chorus are incredibly addicting. Even the clip is pretty hilarious. Overall one of the greatest Pop classics of this decade. 9/10 Listening to that song brings me back horrible memories of my first-year of High School. There was a girl in my class who would always try to embarrass me in front of everyone by saying that she was my girlfriend. She never had any feelings for me; she just wanted to make me feel miserable at every possible opportunity. Anyway, one of her antics was to sing the chorus of "Call Me Maybe" out loud in front of the whole class. It was incredibly embarrassing. As a result, I can't listen to that song without being reminded of my experiences back in Year 7. I was never a fan of that song anyway, so I can't say that i'm disappointed over it.
Telso likes this
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 4, 2019 11:00:54 GMT 10
Listening to that song brings me back horrible memories of my first-year of High School. There was a girl in my class who would always try to embarrass me in front of everyone by saying that she was my girlfriend. She never had any feelings for me; she just wanted to make me feel miserable at every possible opportunity. Anyway, one of her antics was to sing the chorus of "Call Me Maybe" out loud in front of the whole class. It was incredibly embarrassing. As a result, I can't listen to that song without being reminded of my experiences back in Year 7. I was never a fan of that song anyway, so I can't say that i'm disappointed over it. That's ok, I think it's pretty hard in general to dissociate songs and overall pop culture with own personal experiences. That's why one might maybe more objective when evaluating a song's quality when they didn't live through its era than someone who did and was skewed positively/negatively. Having lived through all of the 2010s I also have naturally my own biases in favor of/against certain songs which I will try to put to rest as much as possible. That's one of main the reasons I made this list in the first place: see if I'm able to reevaluate certain songs after all these years .
|
|
|
Post by SharksFan99 on Jan 4, 2019 11:10:29 GMT 10
That's ok, I think it's pretty hard in general to dissociate songs and overall pop culture with own personal experiences. That's why one might maybe more objective when evaluating a song's quality when they didn't live through its era than someone who did and was skewed positively/negatively. Having lived through all of the 2010s I also have naturally my own biases in favor of/against certain songs which I will try to put to rest as much as possibility. That's one of main the reasons: see if I'm able to reevaluate certain songs after all these years . Yep, that's true. I'll be honest, I would find it pretty hard to review songs without adding my own personal bias to it, especially songs that I have strong feelings towards. Just referring back to your original post, how would you review some of the biggest hits of 2010? This will put you to the test, because you might be more nostalgic for the songs since they are from nine years ago, lol.
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 4, 2019 11:21:06 GMT 10
Just referring back to your original post, how would you review some of the biggest hits of 2010? This will put you to the test, because you might be more nostalgic for the songs since they are from nine years ago, lol. I think positive influence from nostalgia isn't that bad, especially if I explain why I like(d) so much in the first place. It's more interesting in comparison to "I hate this song cuz it was so overplayed!!!"-type of arguments As for 2010, I'm personally not a massive fan of (and wasn't really at the time either) and still think that it's a bit of an overrated year (on here especially), so the nostalgia towards the songs at least isn't particularly strong. I like my underappreciated underdogs of 2013 & 2015 a deal better
SharksFan99 likes this
|
|
|
Post by SharksFan99 on Jan 4, 2019 13:42:16 GMT 10
As for 2010, I'm personally not a massive fan of (and wasn't really at the time either) and still think that it's a bit of an overrated year (on here especially), so the nostalgia towards the songs at least isn't particularly strong. I like my underappreciated underdogs of 2013 & 2015 a deal better I don't understand why 2010 is so revered either. It was generally a great year for the Australian music scene (this indie-pop song is one of my favourite songs of the decade), but the music coming out of the US and the UK at the time was pretty sub-par, IMO. With that said, I still do think it was the best year for music this decade, even if the overall quality of Top-40 music wasn't all that great.
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 5, 2019 0:29:25 GMT 10
Justin Bieber - What Do You Mean? (2015)
The true comeback single that marked a big shift in Justin Bieber's career (aside from maybe "Where Are Ü Now" but who even remembers that song?). Gone is the little high-pitched teenager so up of himself with a lousy selection of songs that made him buttloads of haters on the internet, here comes the matured adult artist that learned from past mistakes but also has better producers. And with a great sense of vengeance he unleashed this highly mellow track to earth that went and became a massive, marking a new renaissance for the artist. The lyrics on this are still a bit on the clunky side. I appreciate that Justin promotes the act of trying to understand your partner when they're so indecisive and with constant mood swings to the point of conflict. But "What Do You Mean?" sounds like a bizarrely vague and ingenuine attempt to connect to that person, with not seemingly enough payoff. And basing your whole chorus around that confusing sentiment is pretty asinine. THOUGH I really believe that the great production value strongly outshines the few drawbacks of the lyrics. This song along with "Cheerleader" popular around the same time were strong promoters of the new and fresh, summery sound of Tropical House, and I particularly think that genre is made for Pop crossovers. All the little touches here are just great, from the clock ticking simulating time passing to the pan flutes in the last chorus. "What Do You Mean?" is a little pleasure to take in once in a while. 7/10
Drake - God's Plan (2018)
Drake certainly dominated 2018 with a whopping amount of three megahits that were completely inescapable. Guess which one I liked the most. When it comes to "God's Plan", uhm, I guess it's a quotable enough song like people claim it so hard, though I never particularly cared about that kind of stuff. I do kind of think it does have some clever lines, but half the time the lyrics are so straight and basic. Overall the whole song is kind of non-descript which I think works ok when it comes to Drake. I'm guessing it's about one boasting about the things in live or their own actions being god-send or something, but there's also some basic emotional state discourse. It's not remarkable but the vagueness is sort of unique for mainstream rap so I giving it a pass.
The one thing that doesn't sit right with me though, and probably to a lot of people in general, is how sleepy and monotonous Drake's interpretation seems on the track. There's no energy or bite, and it's seems more like dooze-fest. Drake does have this kind of dooziness quite often, but usually the production complements him well. Here the ambient trance pads work honestly completely against him and only reinforces his seeming sleep talking. The tone is so samey, the song feels like one plateau, with the production having to pause to tell you it's the chorus otherwise you wouldn't be able to notice. At one point around the second verse or so Drake heavens his delivery with more punch, and it's great but it's 5 seconds long, and I just wished the whole song is like that.
It's not BAD since I think it works fairly well as a chill-out, relaxing track where Drake just spits his own feelings and thoughts. But then again there's not much positive I can pinpoint otherwise. It's just kind of there actually, and let's face it: even the video clip completely overshadows the song. 5/10
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 7, 2019 9:52:11 GMT 10
Pharrell Williams - Happy (2014)
Ok, this is definitely a song that needed some reevaluation on my part. I always kind of saw "Happy" as a very insipid song with an annoying hook, and was one of the few songs that overplay killed it for me. A song from the "Despicable Me"-movie also further fueled my disdain for the general childishness of 2014, but I guess I wasn't the right public at the right time.
On isolation and a few years away, "Happy" is actually not that bad at all. It's a basic feel-good Pop Soul song with basic lyrics and a very basic production consisted of the most basic drum claps and progressions, but it works in its context: a light & polite songs, very much made for the kiddies to sing proudly in the car. I also do like the harmonies on the chorus a lot. I still think the song is far too long though, especially with how pointless the last part is, consisting of repeated bridge + hook only to pad the song needlessly and makes the whole thing feel extremely repetitive. 6.5/10
Drake - Nice for What (2018)
A second one from Drake and the second try was the best! "Nice for What" is a jumpy and exalting power-message with so much bounce it could go from New Orleans to the swamps in one jump. This is exactly the punchy Drake I was missing in "God's Plan", as awaken and full of confidence as ever. Fitting for a motivational "You Go Gurl!"-type of message. I absolutely loved the pitch-shifted Lauren Hill sample looping over the solid 808s, it just adds even more excitement to the whole. Not to forget it's a nice shoutout to the Bounce genre with its production, but also featured/sampled Big Freedia vocals. This one is always a joy to listen to. 8.5/10
Rihanna feat. Drake - Work (2016)
Egh… I guess this is somewhat noteworthy for featuring a completely unashamed patois from Rihanna. Lots of people criticized it for making the lyrics misarticulated, but I think the problem here is more how the flow is poor and lethargic so that the patois adds nothing and hinders instead as a result. The lyrics aren't that bad (besides the disgracefully repetitive chorus). They're about her pleading her lover to give the justified recognition in all her effort to love him, which is cute. And then the featured Drake obviously answered to those claims, but also delivering some hilariously bad replies by doing so, like "still prefering her even if she had a twin".
As far as the Dancehall production goes, clearly trying to be a club jam and it is so downbeat that it ends up being some background muzak for the chillout room instead. Pretty graceless song 2/10
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
|
0 |
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 7, 2019 10:12:50 GMT 10
Pharrell Williams - Happy (2014)Ok, this is definitely a song that needed some reevaluation on my part. I always kind of saw "Happy" as a very insipid song with an annoying hook, and was one of the few songs that overplay killed it for me. A song from the "Despicable Me"-movie also further fueled my disdain for the general childishness of 2014, but I guess I wasn't the right public at the right time. On isolation and a few years away, "Happy" is actually not that bad at all. It's a basic feel-good Pop Soul song with basic lyrics and a very basic production consisted of the most basic drum claps and progressions, but it works in its context: a light & polite songs, very much made for the kiddies to sing proudly in the car. I also do like the harmonies on the chorus a lot. I still think the song is far too long though, especially with how pointless the last part is, consisting of repeated bridge + hook only to pad the song needlessly and makes the whole thing feel extremely repetitive. 6.5/10 That's 3.5 points too low don't you think? I heard Get Lucky by Daft Punk. Another 10/10 imo.
|
|
|
Post by Telso on Jan 7, 2019 10:31:08 GMT 10
That's 3.5 points too low don't you think? I heard Get Lucky by Daft Punk. Another 10/10 imo. It just doesn't do a lot for me I'm definitely very on board for "Get Lucky" though!
|
|
|
Post by SharksFan99 on Oct 25, 2019 10:59:38 GMT 10
TelsoNot sure if you plan on continuing this, but here's one for you in case you do. What's your opinion on that new Meduza hit called "Piece of Your Heart"? It's a Euro-House song that has been performing well on the charts across mainland Europe and here in Australia over the past couple of months and since I know that you're into House music in general, i'm just interested to hear what you think of it?
|
|